From the Joy Ride Facebook page:
“Rolex Sydney Hobart 2018 it’s a wrap! No words can express the feeling!! We are utterly exhausted and elated! Will share more info on the race in full later but first some
Finish time December 29th at 10:29 Am PST.”
Such a great adventure!
I hope to talk to skipper John Murkowski or one of the crew and get some of the details. It sounds like
Amid victory cries from Wild Oats XI (WOXI) skipper Mark Richards of “redemption” after a last year’s lost protest and having to drop out the prior year, the amazing super-Maxi beat three others and claimed the coveted first-to-finish. But wait, there’s more. Second place Black Jack skipper Peter Harburg told the press that the WOXI team turned off their Automatic Identification System (AIS) transponder after the start for the duration of the race, which clearly contravened the rules.
But Harburg didn’t protest, leaving it to the race committee to do that. The protest committee, however, denied the protest because it was not filed by the affected competitor.
In the intervening time between Harburg’s claims and the protest being cited as invalid, it became clear that the AIS transponder was working before the start and not during the race. Richards apparently said at one point that it wasn’t required to be working (it was, and that was make quite clear through the sailing instructions and skippers’ meetings). Then it was claimed to be malfunctioning.
Of course, I don’t know the whole situation from this side of the world, but I know that trying to hide one’s position on the racecourse is a time-honored, rinky-dink tactic. From covering a stern light at night to misreporting a mid-race position, it’s been done as long as I can remember. And it’s always been the wrong thing to do. In today’s world and particularly in this race, knowing where all the boats are could save lives. And if it’s written into the rules, which it always is, position reporting is part of the race.
Harburg, the race committee and the protest committee should all be ashamed, taking the easy way out of this. If the AIS transponder was off (which seems to clear, and which surely EVERYBODY knew), it should be checked for malfunction. If it worked, they should be tossed. If it was malfunctioning, that should be made clear. Evading the issue with another time-honored tradition (“Oh, the protest wasn’t valid”) is perpetuating the problem.
There’s significant outrage in the racing community about this. Aussies are tough competitors, but pride themselves on playing games cleanly. I go back to the late Great Dane, Paul Elvstrom, for my take on this:
“You haven’t won the
Kurt grew up racing and cruising in the Midwest, and has raced Lasers since the late 1970s. Currently he is a broker at Swiftsure Yachts. He has been Assistant Editor at Sailing Magazine and a short stint as Editor of Northwest Yachting. Through Meadow Point Publishing he handles various marketing duties for smaller local companies. He currently is partners on a C&C 36 which he cruises throughout the Northwest. He’s married to the amazing Abby and is father to Ian and Gabe.